The most common objection we hear at Starise is "it seems expensive upfront." And it's a fair point — permanent LED roofline lighting isn't the cheapest thing you'll ever buy for your home. But "expensive upfront" and "expensive overall" are very different things.
Let's do the math properly — including costs that most people forget to count — and see what the real 10-year picture looks like.
The baseline: what Calgary homeowners actually spend on temporary lighting
We surveyed our customers before their Starise install and asked what they were spending annually on holiday lighting. Here's what we found across 200 respondents in Calgary:
Professional installation (most common scenario)
- Professional install + removal: $450–$750/year average
- Light replacement and upgrades: $80–$150/year
- Electricity (incandescent): $70–$120/year for a typical home
- Storage hardware: $30–$60/year amortized
Total: $630–$1,080/year for professionally-installed temporary lights
DIY installation (less common as home values rise)
- Light replacement: $80–$200/year
- Electricity: $60–$110/year
- Your time: 8–14 hours/year at your own valuation
- Storage: $20–$50/year amortized
- Ladder and equipment: $50–$100/year amortized
Total (not counting your time): $210–$460/year for DIY
The 10-year cost comparison
| Year | Professional Temp. (cumulative) | DIY Temp. (cumulative) | Starise Permanent (cumulative) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $750 | $340 | $4,500 (install) |
| Year 2 | $1,500 | $680 | $4,560 (+electricity) |
| Year 3 | $2,250 | $1,020 | $4,620 |
| Year 4 | $3,000 | $1,360 | $4,680 |
| Year 5 | $3,750 | $1,700 | $4,740 |
| Year 6 | $4,500 | $2,040 | $4,800 |
| Year 7 | $5,250 | $2,380 | $4,860 ✓ Break-even vs. professional |
| Year 8 | $6,000 | $2,720 | $4,920 |
| Year 9 | $6,750 | $3,060 | $4,980 |
| Year 10 | $7,500 | $3,400 | $5,040 |
What the table doesn't include
The comparison above only covers direct costs. Here are factors that further favour permanent lighting:
Electricity savings
Starise Gen 2 LEDs use approximately 80% less electricity than incandescent Christmas lights and 40% less than standard LED strands. If you're running lights every evening through the holiday season, you can expect to save $40–$80/year on electricity versus a typical LED temporary setup — and more if you were using incandescent.
Time value
If you do your own lights (or manage the process for professionals), you spend 2–4 hours per year coordinating, supervising, and dealing with issues. With Starise, that time goes to zero after install. At $50/hour, that's $100–$200/year in time value recovered.
Year-round use
Temporary lights are used roughly 6 weeks per year — $750 for 42 days of use works out to $17.86/day. Starise customers use their lights year-round for Canada Day, Halloween, Stampede, ambient evening lighting, and more. When you divide the annual cost across 365 days, the per-day cost drops to under $0.20.
No ladder risk
Falls from ladders during Christmas light installation send thousands of Canadians to emergency rooms each year. The financial cost of a ladder-related injury — ER visits, rehabilitation, missed work — is unquantifiable but real. Permanent lighting eliminates this risk entirely.
Home value
Permanent LED roofline lighting is an architectural feature that adds curb appeal. While it's not a structural improvement in the CMHC sense, homes with quality permanent lighting photograph better, show better, and sell faster in Calgary's competitive real estate market.
When does permanent lighting NOT make financial sense?
We try to be honest with every homeowner we speak to. Permanent lighting isn't the right call in every situation:
- You're renting — you can't install it, and you'd leave it behind
- You're selling within 1–2 years — you might not reach break-even (though it may help the sale)
- You do your own lights for free with materials you already own — the DIY break-even is around year 14–16
- You only use lights 2–3 weeks per year — the value-per-use math changes significantly
If any of these apply, we'll tell you upfront. We'd rather give you honest advice than push a product that doesn't serve you.
Frequently asked questions
Find out what the numbers look like for your home
We'll give you a detailed quote and help you run your specific cost comparison. No pressure — just real numbers.
Get a Free Quote →